User talk:ZoeCatfu

Pronouns of another character
Heya! I figured since you're the admin that overruled the wiki's consensus regarding Yamato's pronouns, I felt like you'd want to give your opinion on a similar topic here. Thanks! • Seelentau 愛 議 21:05, September 2, 2020 (UTC)

Yamato discussion
Hey, I may not be an admin here, or even a regular editor, but I wanted to talk about Fandom staff's overruling the Yamato discussion here. To put it simply, I know you people attempted to defuse the discussion, but in reality you've only fanned the flames even further. We had reached a consensus and, quite frankly, you people don't seem to know enough about One Piece to make such a decision. I don't mean this as an insult of any kind, just an observation.

Look, as I said on Yamato's talk page, I myself am a supporter of LGBT+ people in real life. But I genuinely don't think Yamato counts as LGBT+. She is as far as she is presented, not a "man in a woman's body". Yamato is a woman who pretends to be a man simply because she is imitating her hero figure, Kozuki Oden, who was a man. People have, correctly, compared Yamato to Mulan. Mulan pretended to be a man for her own reasons, but that does not mean she was trans.

And besides, we already have a trans character in One Piece, Kikunojo, and we treated her as correctly as we could. Kikunojo clearly stated that, while she is biologically male, she is "a woman at heart" and is referred to as such by everyone, even the narrator. That is not the case with Yamato. As I said before, the infobox in the story itself (and thus the narrator and writer) outright calls Yamato "Kaido's daughter". Which I highly doubt they would do if Yamato really is trans. Timjer (talk) 10:06, September 3, 2020 (UTC)

Agreement
Read me, Click Here

I, along with a number of other people, agree with Timjer and believe that Yamato should not be identified as a member of the trans community. You can read all about it in the link I included.

Her preference to be referred to as male is a matter of her admiration, borderline obsession/delusion (it needed to be said), of Kozuki Oden. It has nothing to do with her gender identity.(GoldenOath20 (talk) 10:50, September 3, 2020 (UTC))