User blog comment:Gametroller Prime/My Game Idea: All Attacks/@comment-24850639-20160308152234/@comment-24850639-20160308204950

Its funny you say that, because I was thinking about AC too. The naval battle system is EPIC. They had it in AC 3 and AC Rogue too, but it was best in Black Flag (not to mention the Pirates! Blackbeard was badass! Unlike his OnePiece counterpart...)

The only thing that sort of deterred me from that is unfortunately we haven't really seen the SH's have a real naval battle yet. Up to this point when other ships have shot at them they've resorted to kicking, cutting, and ballooning (lol) the cannonballs away, rather than straight up fighting back cannons with cannons. When they have pulled out the stops on Sunny, they've used it against ground forces like the Fishmen or Jora.

You have a point about Robin though unfortunately. Oda hasn't really used her as much of a fighter, and the poneglyphs that she's found so far haven't really done a great deal to advance the story. Its been awesome revelations and world-building information, but until this most recent Road poneglyph none of that have IMMEDIATELY impacted the crew. Hard to work her purpose into a game.