Talk:Chapter 985

Yamato for SH
I was editing this and Yamato's page to change "Yamato wants to joing the crew" parts. When we look at the translation, it only says Yamato wants to be given a ride on Luffy's ship. Pedro also wanted to board the ship and saying he wanted to be a Straw-Hat is speculation. For all we know she could just be saying she wants to leave the island on his ship and not see him anymore. Saying more than the information existing in the chapter is not a description that fits the wiki, it's a personal interpretation that adds things that are not in the chapter. I think everyone can agree, but I was met with resistance, so a talk page should settle this. StoopidGuy (talk) 12:04, July 22, 2020 (UTC)

How about something ambiguous so we wouldn't need to go back and fix things later, like " Yamato wishes to leave Wano with Luffy" without indicating the affiliation nor dening it? Rhavkin (talk) 14:42, July 22, 2020 (UTC)

If you look at my edits before they were undone, I used language that is up to interpretation, but that only mentions Yamato's desire to sail in Luffy's ship, as that's all we see in the chapter. StoopidGuy (talk) 14:53, July 22, 2020 (UTC)

"Sailing on Luffy's ship" can mean both for a short while (a ride) or a long duration (membership). "Leaving with Luffy" can only mean after existing Wano every scenario is possible, and since we'll have a clear answer by the end of the arc this will be solved, and this chapter page will say "Yamato ask to leave Wano with Luffy" and the possible joining chapter will say "Yamato decide to join the Straw Hats", with Yamato's page saying "Yamato asked Luffy to leave Wano with his crew,{ref} and later decide to join them permanently.{ref}" Rhavkin (talk) 16:26, July 22, 2020 (UTC)

I agree with your comment here, "leaving Wano" and "be given a ride on his ship" (since that is the official translation) are better than "sailing with Luffy". I think this can be done now, as we're talking about facts from the last chapter and not something that needs a huge discussion to be solved. StoopidGuy (talk) 16:31, July 22, 2020 (UTC)