Forum:Preserving talkpages of deleted articles

Ok,Preserving talk pages of deleted articles may be important since thy might contain valuable arguments leading to it's deletion,.. We can just turn 'em into user subpages,there's no issue of which user will volunteer to hold 'em all as we can use the bots,else this user.


 * So what do ya all think?--

Discussion
Discuss stuff here--

Why an user page? Just make a page "Talk pages archive" and move every talk page as a subpage of that. We should start archiving the talks of big articles (like the straw hats), but this in a subpage of the talk page itself of course.


 * Hehe,I never thought of your idea,yeah that works too:)--

Talk pages of deleted articles must be kept in my opinion. No need to move them to an archive though, just leave them in their place. It could nevertheless be interesting to have a list of all these pages.

While we're talking about it, shouldn't have been deleted.


 * I'm on the side of "keep" the talk pages because its a record of whats gone on before it. HOWEVER, in some cases it leaves these left over pages which might never actually ever be read again and just get lost. As far as users talk pages are concerned, very much keep, as if the user comes back again (bot included) it means other editors are aware of the past history. Archieveing them... I'm not against that for ones that are just junk pages are not likely to be accessed that often. One-Winged Hawk 14:59, August 15, 2011 (UTC)


 * When we meant bot user subpages,we meant to change the page itself into a subpage of a bot(along with it's talk..)--


 * Ah, now I get it (updating seevral pages at once on two wikias at once here, sorry), not it changes anything much of what I just said, I just didn't adress that specific case... 15:09, August 15, 2011 (UTC)

All deleted talk pages that had something on them should be restored. Then they should never be deleted again regardless if the article page is deleted. Or else archive it in the forums. SeaTerror 21:56, August 21, 2011 (UTC)


 * I will note here that sometimes the soul reason for deleting a page and never creating it again can get lost oh so easily. Its better to leave it where it is.  Then again, nonsense pages that have talks should be left deleted. One-Winged Hawk 08:58, August 23, 2011 (UTC)

Yeah agree with u Roraanoa for this one time.The talk pages may contain valuabe information.Example Talk:Fighting_Techniques. 06:01, August 22, 2011 (UTC)

I'm bumping this. We should make a template/category for the deleted articles with talk pages. SeaTerror (talk) 01:29, March 22, 2013 (UTC)