User blog comment:Pandawarrior/What if Luffy and the SHs had joined the Whitebeard Pirates?/@comment-3119203-20111201022439

Ok, to be blatantly honest, this question is pointless because Luffy would never join the WB Pirates. Even if hell froze, Luffy would not do that. So this question assumes that Luffy's personality is totally disregarded, so it is impossible to tell. I dont think he would have learned Gear Second, and Ace still would have been captured. Brook, Robin, and Franky are totally out of the picture, Crocodile is still lurking, Moriah is alive and kicking, Alabasta falls. Period.