User blog comment:Ricizubi/It will be Shirahoshi, if this doesn't convince you even one bit that I give up/@comment-3986064-20110520190225/@comment-1595565-20110520192822

You're just comparing her past to the pasts of other Straw Hats. You're not considering what she brings to the table. Why would the Straw Hats want to command Sea Kings? They don't need that kind of power. Also, she has no fighting abilty whatsoever. Like I said before, she wouldn't fit on the ship, and Luffy's treating her the same way he treated Coby when they first met, which means she has a better chance of becoming a Marine than a pirate. Consider this scenario: She joins the Straw Hats. Then, one day, they are at the center of an island about five miles in radius, nowhere near the beach, and get jumped and surrounded by 600 enemy pirates. What would Shirahoshi do?