Category talk:Fishman Island Locations

Other Locations
Since User:DancePowderer deleted Water Wheel Town, Mermaid Beach, and Marine Shopping Mall (all have significant history originating from Chapter 630), without any reason, I thought I'd bring this up to this talk page. We have many more minor articles that exist on this wiki for towns and other things (see Category:Alabasta Locations, Category:Drum Island Locations, and Category:Sabaody Archipelago Locations). I say we either delete most of those (since most of the locations are minor, and contain the same amount of information that Water Wheel Town, Mermaid Beach, or Marine Shopping Mall would), or allow all the pages to be made, since having some towns, and not others, with no real reason as to why makes zero sense. 03:10, December 10, 2013 (UTC)

I'd say if we have incredibly small articles like John's Candies Shop, they should be merged into a larger article. So for example Candy Factory should be in "Candy Factory Town". The real question is if things like "Candy Factory Town" should just be merged into the larger Fishman Island article. I don't really know if they should or not, but if they remain their own page, then most information about them should be removed from the larger FI article and we should rely on the "See also" template. 05:43, December 10, 2013 (UTC)

Yeah, I agree that John's Candies Shop can be on the Fishman Island page, but the towns, not so much. They have sufficient information to survive as their own pages (as do a good amount of the ones in the categories listed above).

I don't like the fact that they were deleted without any discussion at all though, even though we do have stubbier articles. 05:45, December 10, 2013 (UTC)

Bump, this still hasn't been addressed. It's important in seeing how we should handle future locations. 05:10, December 15, 2013 (UTC)

Bumping this, since the statement above still applies and is still important. DP has also still not replied to this page, after his deletion of the pages. 04:01, January 26, 2014 (UTC)