User blog comment:Dettles/That guy. Meh/@comment-5962458-20131117233452/@comment-2226235-20131120040646

I do read the manga and it isn't speculation to say a person dies from being stabbed through the heart regardless of Oda's style. It is speculation to say that she survived a stab through the heart because Oda rarely kills characters. Besides, it was decided on the talk that she is considered dead until further notice.