One Piece Wiki:Speculations

What is Speculation?
A prediction of what will happen in a series, usually made by a fan of the series.

Does Speculation have a place on wikia?
No. It should be avoided at all costs. Wikia is a site for facts, and speculation is usually just Fanfiction. Sometimes, it is possible to rewrite speculation into fact, but if speculation is spotted, the normal treatment is to delete it.

It is also possible to write popular theories that appear amongst fans, provided that there is a suitable amount of evidence as to why the theory is considered plausible. However, without such evidence, the theory is not very useful and is obviously nothing more then pure, unproven speculation.

See Mythbusters for more rumours and myths related to One Piece.

How do I spot Speculation?
The most obivous way is someone opening with the words 'It is speculated...' in their statements. Less noticable ones may have the words, 'It is unknown why...' and then the speculation written. Be careful with this as it is easy to fall into a trap. For example, writing something such as "It is unknown why Ace has a different surname to Luffy" is not speculation and therefore allowed. However, adding, "This may be because they are only half-brothers" is speculation as it has not been proven whether they are or not.

There is also nothing to stop someone pointing out the obvious - like stating that, so far, all the Ds (in the Will of D.) live by their hearts. Sometimes these statements may end up sounding like speculation, when they are not. This is another instance where things seem like speculation, but are not.

Speculation can be Dangerous!
As with Spoilers, speculation can be dangerous. Whether on purpose or accidentally, they can mislead a reader or give the wrong idea. There are some fans who may unknowingly regard them as fact; this has led to many myths amongst the English-speaking fandom.

If you have speculation you want to discuss, there are many forums out there where you can freely discuss ideas and speculations, and get feedback. It is advisable to avoid writing them here.

I'm still not sure on Speculation...
Remember, don't be afraid to ask!

Discussing the statment on the Talk page of the given article is usually the best way of writing out something if you are unsure about it. Other editors can provide advice on if it should be added, or help you rewrite it to fit in the page.

You will gain more respect from other editors and avoid embarrassment if you are prepared to talk about how to approach a topic rather then just writing it out.

Alternatively, if you are unsure about writing a statement on a page, you can just not write it at all.