User blog comment:Fliu/Chapter 928 Thoughts/@comment-24850639-20181228154737/@comment-2600:8807:C00:53D0:293E:A57E:4A6:88A0-20181230022930

If Shanks took Kid's arm, then why didn't he just say Shanks took it instead of saying the Red Hair Pirates took it?

Besides, we haven't seen the wound clearly enough to tell if it was just cut off. Could have been ripped off or blown off for all we know. They are a Emperor crew after all.