User blog comment:Ricizubi/It will be Shirahoshi, if this doesn't convince you even one bit that I give up/@comment-3252861-20110520175357

HAHAHAHA! I'm sorry, but you said Shirahoshi doesn't has charisma of a leader. Agree. But believe she has 100 times more charisma of a leader than a pirate. Also Shirahoshi can be a protector of the Island, not the leader. You say she has will lose her mother like Robin and Nami, but Nami at the age of 17 she was already a fighter. Shirahoshi have less experience than Coby. Even Ace was more suited at the age of 10 than Shirahoshi and Shanks said no one with so little experience should be a pirate. Also you said about Luffy calling cry-baby Shirahoshi like he did with Coby, but Coby didn't become a pirate.