User blog comment:Blackendedsoul/Buggy's Shock!/@comment-4820500-20120314055919/@comment-3425840-20120314103737

Well we have already discussed it before In the link of the blog that I gave in this blog but I will say is again in brief, Luffy's body always stays rubber but Buggy's body normally stays in one iece (no pun intended). If what you said was the case then like Luffy was still stretchable under water, Buggy when fell into the sea would have split into pieces which did not happen.