User blog comment:Allison309/Nami or Hancock/@comment-4493594-20120831205526

Sigh... I'm afraid this wiki is the wrong place to ask that kind of question as we handle "fandom" in a rather conservative way. Maybe you should check out tumblr instead.

Anyways, if his crew's lives depended on Luffy getting married I'd say he would pick shitty Nami simply because she is the next best female available. If she said no, he'd probably ask Robin next. Then he'd just ask around randomly and maybe later remember how crazy Hancock was about marrying him and ask her. Not out of feelings but just because he's Luffy.