Forum:Yamato Gender

Recently the higher ups decided to list Yamato as transgender on very sketchy and flimsy reasons and ignore anyone givng valid evidence against it regardless of how valid it is. Yamato has been listed as female in the Vivre Card, The Women of One Piece promo, and The Road To Laugh Tale Part 3 manga chapter. People have been ingnoring these facts thinking they know better than Oda, the guy wrote this series. It really reeks of LGBT pandering towards whiners who most likely have never even heard One Piece before her introduction and don't understand than Japan has a different way of writing pronouns and that can get a bit muddled it translation. So stop bending the knee too people don't even like One Piece or understand Japanese culture, for many like me this is a go to site for One Piece information and it should be written professionally and accurately instead of catering to activists and trying to win brownie points with them.Ssj4vegetto (talk) 03:42, 24 July 2022 (UTC)

All the sources you list are considered secondary to the primary source, which is the manga. And in there, Yamato is described with male pronouns.

The translation is also not inaccurate. We too consult translators, unless you know Japanese more than them. Every discussion on this subject has been documented in the character's talk page and you're free to consult it. KingCannon (talk) 15:30, 24 July 2022 (UTC)