User blog comment:Monkey.D.Me/DFs BACK from DEAD !!!/@comment-26408630-20120129034405/@comment-3075024-20120129041942

I agree with you Tucky on the Bosa one. We have not seen his dead body yet so we don't have proof that he is dead. But still, according to One Piece and from what characters in One Piece know(Luffy, Ace and other people from Goa Kingdom), Bosa is dead so I think we have to go with them.

Now the case of Brook and Oars is complicated. Well brook died and then revived so he is special case and there is nothing that can be done but Oars and other zombies like Cindry .. .. I still have mixed feelings about them.