Category talk:Dead Characters

Oh no...
As predicted, several characters whose death might be argued with amongst ourselves have recently been included in this category. There are several characters here that some might not think be dead due to Oda's rule and due to lack of evidence. Nelson, Erik the Whirlwind, Bear King, and even Miss Monday, are some whose "deaths" I myself don't think might be legit yet they have been added. So instead of causing a major ruckus amongst ourselves, can we discuss if we really need this category.Mugiwara Franky 01:06, 14 February 2007 (UTC)
 * I don't see a problem with the category in theory, but it seems that people do have varying opinions on whether a character is dead or not... And it is a little difficult to judge when we have things like Pell's magical survival throwing it off. XD If this was a different series I'd probably feel comfortable saying Mr. 9 and Miss Monday are dead, but with One Piece, it's very hard to say that... I think we should either just eliminate the category entirely or make it only be characters that have had their deaths confimed in one way or another (which isn't that many, I think? It looks like only about 12 or so of the characters on the page have confirmed deaths, a few more if you count people like Olvia, Clover, and Roji)... But I don't know what everyone else thinks. ^^;; --Murasaki 02:43, 14 February 2007 (UTC)