File talk:Luffy Pays His Respects.jpg

Colour image
Please discuss whether u need this picture or not here:

Let us keep Colour image.It is better one 12:03, August 23, 2011 (UTC)

I agree. I like the colored version better. :3 2 0 % c o ol er 12:12, August 23, 2011 (UTC)

no! the whole point of the image is that it's a message for the straw hats IN THE NEWSPAPER!!! it's not up for discussion, it will stay the image from the newspaper. the colored image doesn't have a good quality either, and the newspaper does, so we can't use the colored image. Strawhat1 15:44, August 23, 2011 (UTC)

We should just gather all the opinions, otherwise we will never accomplish anything. Just sign under the version you prefer, remember this is to gather all the opinions so it won't have a deadline (like a poll). Wait before there are at lest 5-10 votes, before take the results in consideration. Remember to take in account the purpose of the picture (if there is one in particular), maybe check on what pages it's used.

Which version?
There are currently (15:57, August 23, 2011 (UTC)) 4 versions:


 * 1st: Manga version (02:07, 30 lug 2010)


 * 2nd: Anime (newspaper) version (04:12, 16 ago 2011) (later uploaded with the HQ version of 18:19, 23 ago 2011)


 * 3rd: Anime (newspaper - cutted) version (03:23, 21 ago 2011) (later uploaded with the HQ version of 18:26, 23 ago 2011)
 * 1) Strawhat1 16:06, August 23, 2011 (UTC)


 * 4th: Anime (colored scene) version (18:22, 21 ago 2011) (later uploaded with the HQ version of 18:18, 23 ago 2011)
 * 14:35, August 24, 2011 (UTC)


 * Neutral/Indecisive
 * 1)  (one of the newspaper one, see Newspaper)

Discussion
Discuss here. For example, state your reasons or what do you think the purpose of the picture is.

i don't think we need to vote, it's obviousthat we need to use the newspaper image because it has so much more significance. we can't use the colored one just because it's "prettier", and because the message on luffy's arm isn't very clear in the colored version. Strawhat1 18:55, August 23, 2011 (UTC)

Ok but there are still 3 version of the "newspaper", so if we use the poll we can avoid discussion.

so can we lose the colored option? Strawhat1 15:46, August 24, 2011 (UTC)

It is not only usage in article that is important.It does not look good with newspapwer version. 09:15, August 26, 2011 (UTC)

it's good enough for a newspaper image, and the whole point of this image is the newspaper, so that's why it stays. Strawhat1 16:43, August 26, 2011 (UTC)