Talk:Poseidon

Categorization
Should we really put the categories "merfolk" and "female" here? I mean, the article is about the "power" of the "weapon", not a person in particular. 06:21, December 10, 2011 (UTC)

I agree. It's about the power, not the vessel. 06:30, December 10, 2011 (UTC)

Are we sure? Technically the power isn't Poseidon... Poseidon was the mermaid princess of 800 years ago who had this power, so by extension who also have this power is called Poseidon. Hence this article should be about a person who was considerate a weapon. I think we should add both, or not?

Copy + paste =/= best method of merging
As I said bfore, most of whats written on the Mermaid Princess is already on here. All you had to do was transfer ther missing information, not literally copy + past the entire page from Mermiad Princess. Come on, that only amounts to lazy editing, like you can't be bothered to fit the information within the wikia's standard format. Never mind I fixed it so the information is now correctily put into the article.. -_- One-Winged Hawk 12:19, January 31, 2012 (UTC)

Person vs. Weapon
I was looking over this page, and I was wondering, was Poseidon the name of the mermaid Joy Boy knew, or is it just the name of the weapon? If it is a name, should we split the two and call one "Poseidon" and the other "Poseidon (Weapon)"? 19:42, December 6, 2017 (UTC)

Poseidon was the name of the ancient mermaid and then, par excellence, the name was inherited by Shirahoshi. I feel the article should focus more on the ancient mermaid, though, rather then focusing on the generic "weapon". I don't think it's necessary to split the page.