User blog comment:Zoro-san/Guess the character/@comment-4402444-20111107040636

No, he isn't. And I just took a good amount of time applying the process of elimination to all non-canon characters, and got nowhere. For those of you who are trying to solve this, here's what I know for certain:

The character is male, human, non-canon (which means he wasn't in the manga at any point, including Romance Dawn), unimportant, not old and not young, not a pirate and not a Marine, not a Devil Fruit user, not a good fighter, not an ally of Luffy's (which pretty much eliminates everyone from Little East Blue), doesn't appear between the time the Straw Hats enter the Grand Line and the time they leave Water 7 on the Thousand Sunny, didn't appear in any movie, and, by process of elimination, is either in the North Blue, South Blue, West Blue, Calm Belt, or is dead.

Now, here's what I've assumed:

We know a significant amount of information about the character including where the character is originally from, since we know he isn't from the North, West, or South Blue, and we know that he isn't a good fighter.

That's all I've got; see if that helps you genii figure this out.