User blog comment:The ASL Pirates/New Age Comparisons/@comment-4311467-20150617042842/@comment-4708535-20150617052614

For Smoker -  Garp comparison, Garp and Roger had countless battles,  Smoker is the marine who luffy has most encountered (except garp - well he is family)  about 5 times, so I can relate that to Roger -  Garp relationship.