Talk:Tsumegeri Guards

Disbanded?
The Tsumegeri Guards as an organisation are the elite guards of Alabasta. To assume that they disbanded as an organisation just because the members at that time perished is speculative. It's different for pirate crews since they're not part of a bigger organisation like the Alabasta Royal Guard, but in the case of the Tsumegeri Guard it is likely that they'll have been replaced. Slush 17:20, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

"It is likely" does not have a place here, it is speculation, we have absolutely NO IDEA if the Tsumegeri guards still exist or not FOR SURE. If we are not sure, then we should just not mention it.

Then we shouldn't mention that they disbanded either. Slush 17:26, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

So you're saying that we shouldn't include that they died in the article? We don't know if they were replaced, so we should only go with what we know for certain. They all died, hence, at that moment, the group was no more. We can say nothing more, nothing less about them from that point on. 17:46, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

They are dead.. R.I.P Tsumegeri Guards.