Talk:Organ Dealing Assassination Group

Wolf
I'm pretty sure the wolf guy is a zoan user and not a mink, his claws are way too curved and long (unlike the flat pointed fingernail like ones the minks have) and his build is wrong (elongated feet and hunched stance)

BURUni (talk) 17:42, May 6, 2018 (UTC)

We already have a wolf Zoan.

18:26, May 6, 2018 (UTC)

Names of Members
According to the subtitles the following "names" were provided next to their respective lines:

ガム (Gum) for the guy with the glasses.

オペラ座 (Opera-za) for the guy with the mask which means Opera as in Opera House. As for why it would say Opera-za instead of Opera is beyond me, but I find it hard to believe that if this was a description, it would use a building.

ウルフ (literally Wolf) for the Wolf. This is likely just a direct description as opposed to a name.

150 for the muscled man. It literally says the numbers 150, which makes this (as weird as it may seem) seem like it isn't a description, otherwise he would just be called muscle man in Japanese. I have no clue what "150" would even describe which kinda points to it not being a description.

I searched them on google in Japanese and they are treated as names by people who have posted about them. I personally feel like 150 and Gum could be names, Opera-za being less likely and Wolf being the least (although still possible).Nightmare Pirates (talk) 05:42, July 12, 2020 (UTC)

I would think that they are all names, but I don't know if the Japanese subtitles use placeholders or actual names. Do we have any other examples to go by? Also, would we give them their own pages, or add a section describing each member like the Super Spot-Billed Duck Troops or Tsumegeri Guards? 11:03, July 12, 2020 (UTC)

For example the subtitles name characters like "crab gifter", without giving a name. But in this case at least Gum and 150 are pretty sure names, I mean there is a guy called Aggie 68 so why not 150. And unlike the ducks this have unique desings so they'd have their own page. Cracker-Kun (talk) 11:15, July 12, 2020 (UTC)

Usually the subtitles use names that end with something like "man" or an occupation for unnamed random characters. For example, those Totto Land "ministers" that were revealed in credits of the anime were referred as the "Lady Minister" or "Chin Minister". If they don't end like that then they usually have some pretty obvious descriptors like one of Big Mom's subordinates was credited as 三つ編み (which means braids when translated, referring to his braided hair), but that is a pretty straightforward descriptor as opposed to some of these. However, I am hesitant on the masked man because his name literally means "Opera House" which likely refers to Phantom of the Opera ("オペラ座" means Opera House/Opera), but that is quite a stretch of a descriptor to describe someone as an Opera House. Also, and again, I can't even fathom what 150 could even describe. Gum could be because he is chewing gum, but we also have had Glove for over a decade and he was listed in subtitles as "Glove Commander" and we took that to mean "Commander Glove" as opposed to "the commander wearing gloves."Nightmare Pirates (talk) 11:57, July 12, 2020 (UTC)

So based on the Glove case, at least Gum should have an article. Cracker-Kun (talk)

Been 2 months, without opposition.--Nightmare Pirates (talk) 03:49, September 10, 2020 (UTC)

They seem like mere descriptors. 07:47, September 10, 2020 (UTC)

Since Kaido already made pages for Gum and 150, are we going to make pages for Opera and Wolf? 00:08, September 12, 2020 (UTC)

Pages for all members have been made. Opera and Wolf were justified because they were written in katakana like Opera and Wolf. Discussion closed. 19:39, September 13, 2020 (UTC)