User talk:Retro7

Check first
The Eyeshield 21 tribute was before Hildon came along so it cannot be a response to Oda's character.

BTW the mangaka of S.Jump are friends so this is all pretty normal for them. --One-Winged Hawk 21:25, 6 July 2008 (UTC)


 * Okay let me explain, you might first want to read Mythbusters and check up the bit about references. Basically, we get a LOT of references added to trivia, most way off.  To be fair, we must way all the options up and decide if its legit, esp. when Oda says nothing.  Some things are obivous they can stand; Chopper's ref to a certain red-nosed reindeer, Jango's ref to a certain former member of the Jackson 5.  Others are vague... We didn't have Brook's references on for a while because the tal thin skeleton, I've seen that a number of times, even before a certain film came out.


 * Take in mind, we've had acclaimed references from just about everything. We've got enough evidence to prove Oda takes from music stars a lot, so we can confirm a lot of the references for musicains.  Beyond that... We've had acclaimed references for Blackbeard and Wario, to give one example.  Basically, while we allow it on occusion, we have to put a limit in place.  Take in mind, the exhaggurated expression has been in the cartoon industry for well over 50 years, we can't say 100% sure where references like that come from.  One-Winged Hawk 07:02, 5 April 2009 (UTC)

Ugh, how my reference any different from the other speculation on some pages? You were certainly willing to ref Nightmare Before Christmas on the Kuraigana Island page or Rocky Horror for Iwa. And keep in mind I say "maybe" I never said it was fact. Am sorry but it just looks way to similar to that scene to be just another cookie cutter face fault, heck I hardly even see that expression in any toon at all. And trust me, being a cartoonist I've seen bug out expression before, Kemi's hardly comes up. The fact Oda even mention Burton's work even pushes this theory further. Side it just one little trivia bit, its not gonna hurt the page.66.53.83.202 08:21, 5 April 2009 (UTC)


 * We had confirmations for Brook and the Nightmare before Christmas, our patience rewarde us in that case along with confirmations for also the Adams' family (not even thought up at the time). PeeWee wasn't the first to use that face fault, I've seen it from an old comic book before, abide I can't remember the name.  I had this same argument for Brook, Jack-whathisname, wasn't the only tall skinny skeleton. On the Rocky Horror thing, I haven't pauid attention to that, I admit... I need to fix that.  One-Winged Hawk 08:35, 5 April 2009 (UTC)

Marineford Arc
Hello Retro7, I'm currently having a discussion with One-Winged Hawk about the Marineford Arc article (Talk:Marineford_Arc). According to the history, I have the impression that you are one of the major contributor to this page, so it shall be worth to have your opinion on the subject. Thanks Kdom 12:02, October 11, 2009 (UTC)