Talk:Sakura Kingdom

I don't think this deserves its own page
Sorry if this was already discussed, but I don't really see any point in having this page.

I was doing some adjustment in the Drum island page and noticed that its history section was very barebones probably because of this page. This page's history can easily be told in the Drum Island page. Heck, the one trivia point it could have is located on the Drum island page as well. KingCannon (talk) 01:20, February 12, 2016 (UTC)

This wiki seems to have inconsistencies with island names vs. kingdom names, for example this as well as Zou vs. Mokomo Dukedom. Meanwhile, Sandy Island is not its own page but is rather mentioned in Alabasta, and Kamabakka Kingdom is part of Momoiro Island. I would support moving this to Drum Island and possibly Mokomo Dukedom to Zou since the island names have a higher recognition factor. 01:35, February 12, 2016 (UTC)

The inconsistencies are mostly caused by the fact that characters themselves are inconsistent with the names they use for places (in a case-by-case basis), thus, I suppose the wiki usually has to go with the more recognizable name.

For example, very few people in and out-of-universe call Alabasta and Goa Kingdom as Sandy Island and Dawn Island, respectively (same for Kamabakka Kingdom). Meanwhile, a lot of people (again, in and out-of-universe) mostly use Drum Island, Fishman Island and Zou to refer to the snowy country, the fishman country and the elephant country.

Maybe this is all because of convenience, with people using the shortest or easiest name to remember. Heck, most fans probably don't know what Sandy Island is.

But alas, the problem here is that Sakura Kingdom by itself doesn't add anything as its own page.KingCannon (talk) 03:12, February 12, 2016 (UTC)

This should be a forum discussion if we're talking about multiple articles. 16:53, February 22, 2016 (UTC)