Talk:Island Climatic Types

Name
Should this page talk about the weather in general instead of only the island climatic types? We can add particular phenomenas like the "lighting rain" or the "candy rain" (after thriller bark), or more commons one like typhoons... well maybe this are obvious so we don't have to.

Oh yeah, I can totally imagine that. Sounds good to me. 19:51, June 6, 2011 (UTC)

I agree with Levi on this. There should be a page about the weaher of the Grand Line, where this page will be merged into(or this page will be renamed and more things will be added) which should contain the types of climate on each island and that way there would be no argument for "special cases"(if the climate of each island gets described and also the only confirmed special case is Rusukaina)

I think this should be discussed, as there are many islands on the Grand Line and phenomenas like those of which levi was talking about.

I also agree that this should be renamed/remade into a more general climate page. Bastian964 20:31, November 16, 2011 (UTC)

We don't need a page as broad as general climate. It's fine as is. We explain each type of climate and weather, and give examples. Making a page about general weather in the One Piece world would be a lot of work with not much to show for it in the end. 22:36, November 16, 2011 (UTC)

Special Climatic Types
I just noticed, but I don't remember Little Garden being a special case, for the weather at least. It's special because it's a prehistoric island, but the weather doesn't look abnormal...

I think it is considered special because of how Kureha commented on Nami's illness. Apparently her affliction was caused by an insect that is actually extinct because it usually needs a certain climate to survive. This suggests that Little Garden is extra special, even for grand line standards. 21:11, June 6, 2011 (UTC)

Even so, would not it still be considered a summer island of some sort?Hadomaru 19:04, September 12, 2011 (UTC)

Trivia
About this trivia: "Nami realizes how to "ride" Reverse Mountain when she realized it was a Winter Island. This does not follow because it was Vivi who told them about the different islands and had not yet joined them." though it's true, I don't think it's a contradiction because in chapter 132 when Vivi explained the Island Climatic Types Nami was sick in her bed and she never listened to Vivi's explanation to begin with, hence she could have just known it by herself, she is a navigator after all.