Talk:Explosive

Needed?
I think yes but if anyone disagree go ahead. Rhavkin (talk) 10:53, November 13, 2017 (UTC)

Pamu Pamu no Mi and Tamatebako
I think the Pamu Pamu is close enough to be consider explosive because is it compered to the Bomu Bomu no Mi on multiple pages (its own and the Donquixote Pirates'), and it is stated to cause explosions.

The Tamatebako has a bomb of an unknown type inside of it, since its survived a fall from the roof the another floor and did not detonate when Du Feld peaked inside so I think its worth mentioning. Rhavkin (talk) 10:53, November 13, 2017 (UTC)

The devil fruits (bomb bomb and pamu pamu) should not be listed in the bombs section. They could be mentioned in a trivia or "see also" section, but by listing thme in the "bombs" section you are implying they are bombs. They are not, they are devil fruits. The same goes for the tamatebako: by listing it with other explosives you are assuming it is an explosive, but it's not. You said it yourself: the tamatebako has an explosive inside it, but the tamatebako itself is not an explosive. Like with the devil fruits, it would be fine mentioning it in a trivia / see also section, but it should not be mixed with the actual explosives.

The Bomu Bomu no Mi should be in the bombs section because its power is that of bombs. Its like saying the biscuits from the Bisu Bisu no Mi aren't biscuits.

The Pamu Pamu no Mi is indeed not a bomb, but it does generate explosions which is way I suggest to name this page "Explosives" instead of Rgilbert27's suggestion "Bombs". The Tamatebako was the thing that exploded. It was the casing of the explosive materiel. Every one said "the Tamatebako will explode" not "the bomb inside the Tamatebako will explode".The Tamatebako has an unknown type of explosive inside of it. Maybe they shouldn't be mentioned at the bombs sections but the "Others" section? Rhavkin (talk) 11:58, November 13, 2017 (UTC)


 * "Its like saying the biscuits from the Bisu Bisu no Mi aren't biscuits." - that's the point, what the Bisu Bisu no Mi produces are biscuits, but the Bisu Bisu no Mi is not a biscuit. What you are saying here is that the Bomu Bomu no Mi is a bomb which is not true.
 * Every one said "the Tamatebako will explode" not "the bomb inside the Tamatebako will explode". - that's just a figure of speech. Pedro and Pell blew themselves up, should we listed them as explosives? I don't think so. Same for the tamatebako. The tamatebako was just a vessel for the explosive (and not a natural one, since that's not its purpose).

I'm just suggesting to move these ones in the trivia section or in a see also section. They will still be mentioned on the page, so there won't be a "loss of content". What exactly don't you like about that?

I rewrote the bomu part to specify the fruit itself is not a bomb. The pamu was moved to "other explosives". The Tamatebako was filled with explosive material, making it a bomb however you look at it but you are right, the box itself is not a bomb. I moved it the a trivia section for now and I want to suggest to not edit until other users speak their mind on the subject. Rhavkin (talk) 14:46, November 13, 2017 (UTC)

Look when it comes to suicide bombers like Hiluluk (Chapter 145 (p. 10) Panel 1 Episode 86) and Pedro (Chapter 877 (p. 16-17) Panel 14) or attempted suicide bombers like Dalton (Chapter 151 (p. 12) Panel 5 Episode 89) and that soldier from the Neptune Army (Chapter 631 (p. 8-9) Episode 551) Pell was trying to move the bomb a safe distance away from bystanders (Chapter 208 (p. 18-19) Panel 1 Episode 125) and as there a few to be named we should make a section to distinguish them from the other explosives users. For images we could make galleries like Firearms and Axes using images from (Chapter 144 (p. 11) Panel 6 Episode 86) and (Chapter 208 (p. 3) Panel 1 Episode 125) for starters, also in my search the earliest mention for the World Government I can think of is (Chapter 151 (p. 6) Panel 3 Episode 89) another reason we need Appearances because there's lack of info. Rhavkin I have read and watched One Piece, even the 4Kids dub, for years and I can't recall Grenades being used whatsoever if you could provide your source or the reference that would be good. Lastly for Firearms could we include sections on arrows, flamethrowers, bazookas and so on because there are other firearms besides flintlocks, muskets and cannons.--Rgilbert27 (talk) 18:30, November 13, 2017 (UTC)

Law had several grenades in chapter 752. There might have been earlier appearances but That is the first I remember.

A gallery is usually for something named and\or with a separate page, and I don't think it would work here.

As for the rest of the thing you mentioned, I do not think this is the place for them. Rhavkin (talk) 18:52, November 13, 2017 (UTC)