Forum:Raw and scan images policy: vote

It's about time to start the voting process for the raw and scan images policy. This forum is the continuation of the topic of Forum:RAW Japanese Manga Images, so if you don't know what are we talking about read it before voting.

Note: ''The issue of choosing between raw and scans is present only when there is text in the image. Watermarked images are not accepted in any case, since they violated our image guidelines and the scanlation groups' terms of use (like mangastrem).''

Poll
1. Allowing the use of scanlation images with fan-made English text? (without blank out the speech bubbles)
 * Yes. Examples:




 * No, remove the text added by the scanlation group. (except special cases) Examples:




 * Neutral.

2. Order of preference between images (raws/scans):
 * When a good scan is available, there is no need to upload the raw one. Examples:




 * When a good raw is available, update the scan image with the raw one. Examples:




 * Choose the raw over the scan regardless the quality. Examples:



The scan: The raw: The scan: The raw:
 * Other comparison between raw/scans:


 * Neutral.

2.1 For chapter covers:
 * Use always the scans. Examples:




 * Until the raw cover will be out, use the scan cover.


 * There is no need to upload the cover, wait the raw. (usually a few days at maximum) Examples:




 * Neutral.

If you have other suggestion about other examples or other options write them down in the discussion.

Discussion
I can clean the bad quality images, if necessary, so tell me which files needs to be cleaned.

About the raw/scan, I don't see the point to use the scans (except for the special cases), since the picture are meant to show the art or a subject, if you want read the text you go to a online manga reader, also in the caption or in the test is described what happens in the picture. Remember that this is an encyclopedia. But this is only about the fan text, not the picture itself.