User blog comment:Portgas D.Eros/Vice Admirals vs Warloards/@comment-3103150-20101011144848/@comment-2231298-20101012020208

Who says that both of them are in the giant squad? As I've already tried to point out a squad of all Vice Admirals makes no sense. You did try to claim that all giants in the Maries were Vice Admirals. Here's what you said: "The giants all appear to be vice admirals, as all the Marine giants who have appeared have been vice admirals: Saul, John Giant, Lacroix, and Ronse." What you said there is that because they're in the Marines and they're giants, they must be Vice Admirals. The only linking factors between them is that they're all giants and they're in the Marines. If there were more giants in the marines, why weren't they at the war? Surely their pure size and physical strength would be enough of an asset to call them in, even fighting against Haki users, especially when they had hundreds of human soldiers who were ill equipped to fight against Haki users. There is simply no reason to assume that all of the giants at the war are Vice Admirals.

I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree on this. I don't think either of us will be able to convince the other to change their view. I'll stop posting on this talk now.