Forum:Conjectural Titled Articles: What to Do?

About the conjectural titled articles, what are we gonna do about them? I mean, some are worth keeping, like important characters such as the fake members of the Impostor Straw Hat Pirates who have yet to have their real names revealed. But others, like Crocodile's Hook or Sabaody Archipelago Marine Base, can be merged into their respective official pages (Crocodile and Sabaody Archipelago, respectively). And then others, like Super-Human Speed and Great Doctor Hunt, they don't seem to have too much official naming (no kanji, no romanization, etc.), and don't hold much ground on this Wikia, and should be deleted or, in the case of events and battles, merged story arcs and saga articles. Yatanogarasu 09:20, March 2, 2011 (UTC)
 * I mean, if we find official names with kanji and romanization for these articles (especially the events and battles), then we can keep them, and make them officially named pages. Yatanogarasu 09:29, March 2, 2011 (UTC)

You have a point right here..Well my opinion for deleting is :Great Doctor Hunt,the Great War who can be on Void century,and the first two that you are talking about..As well as Bomb Collar, maybe we can put it somewhere else and dont have a page on its own..Also we can put Super Flashy Raft on Buggy's page..Thats my opinion.-- undefined

 LuffyPirateKing ::  Talk   13:52, March 2, 2011 (UTC)

The ones you said that could be merged should be, like Crocodile's Hook, and Sabaody Marine Base. As for the events, I say they should be merged with their location or the main person involved. So Great Doctor Hunt would go with either Drum or Wapol, and Superhuman Speed could go with Rokushiki, since that seems to be the most common use of it. Bomb Collar should stay its own thing, or be changed to Explosive Collar (I think that was the actual wording used). And yeah, Great War belongs on the Void Century page. 14:03, March 2, 2011 (UTC)

Super human speed should not be deleted. Also it is not a conjectural title because it is titled exactly what it is. SeaTerror 15:11, March 2, 2011 (UTC)

Good that you bring this up Yatanogarasu.

Lets gather ideas individually:

Arabasta Rebellion


 * Definitely worth keeping, should be merged with Arabasta (fits, part of the countries history), or Arabasta arc

Bomb Collar


 * God I hate pages with 3-4 lines of text. But anyway, I think this fits great into the human auction house article. After all it is a gadget exclusively used there, at least I can't name another place.

Brook's Managers -


 * Merge with Long arm tribe article

Crocodile's Hook -


 * Merge with crocodile

Edward Newgate's Bisento


 * Same case, merge with Whitebeards article

Emporio Ivankov's Dancers


 * Pondering between Ivankov and Okama there, but I think they should belong to Ivankov's article, maybe to the relationship section.

Enel's Survival Game


 * Either merging with the Upper Yard article, or Skypiea arc. Tending to Upper Yard

Enel's Warriors


 * Tough, I would not touch this article. Enel's Warriors is basically a faction, no idea if we can merge it that easily

Fake Chopper, Fake Franky, Fake Nami, Fake Sogeking, Fake Zoro


 * We could merge them into one article, but then we have another monster page. Maybe use the tab-style?

Fencing Style/Franky Schematics


 * Merge with Brook's/Franky's page

Goa King


 * Merge with Goa Kingdom

Great Doctor Hunt


 * Merge with Drum Island or Drum Island arc

Great War


 * Merge with void century

Kalifa's Father


 * Merge with Kalifa's page, maybe add a relationship paragraph

Kaya's Father


 * Merge with Kaya's page, to the relationship section

Lvneel Expedition Doctor


 * Uhm, not sure if this is even worth keeping...

Lvneel King


 * Merge with Nolands page, if possible

Oharan Clan


 * Merge with Ohara clan

Sabaody Marine Base


 * Merge with Sabaody Achipelago

Sabo's Father / Sabo's Mother


 * Merge with Sabo's article

Snake Weapon


 * Merge with Kuja tribe

Standard Marine Ships


 * Fine as it is, imho.

Super Flashy Raft


 * Is this really necessary? Reminds me of Yatanogarasu's Harry Potter Wikia example, with the Ink and Birthday cake article. Delete.

Super-Human Speed


 * Troublesome and really strange page. I will spare my opinion about it, else I drift away from the topic.

Wapol's Father


 * Merge with Wapol's article

World of One Piece


 * Keep it as it is.

'''Feel free to add your own suggestions to the list. I just think it is more sorted that way and saves us trouble in the long run (else we face "why is this deleted brah brah brah" - comments in the future)''' 16:08, March 2, 2011 (UTC)