Talk:One Piece: Grand Adventure

Each Video Games getting their own page
Why can't we give each One Piece Video Game their own page? We don't need to link each to the list of Video Games

Okay
I like the idea, but I don't know enough about the games.


 * Neither do I. There's a ton of really sucking OP games out there, especially apparently on handhelds, like the GBA. I think we should have a list with short descriptions and can get into detail on pages, for the large ones only. Stuff like the Grand Battle games, Pirate's Carnival, Grand Adventure (I own the last 2, one is in Japanese) and Unlimited Adventure (I'll get it once there's a Wii FreeLoader or I can get a Japanese Wii). I don't think most of the GBA games(there's a list you can look up on wikipedia of all of them) and a few others deserve pages, while some do. This one is only a temporary Redirect until I can right a page about it, Which I am working on, same for Pirate's Carnival. Cody2526 21:42, 12 December 2006 (UTC)

Well I believe small games should deserve their own page with small description better but that's what I like to do.

Joekido


 * If the game only has a few sentences, and everything after that is filler information to make it longer, it doesn't deserve a page, even a stub. If you can't make 2 full Paragraphs just have a Paragraph description on the list page, and the full page in it's name will redirect to the list. On the other hand big games with tons of information regarding how they work(pirate's carnival, Grand Adventure) deserve their own pages. Until they are written they should probably just be redirects to the list. Once somebody writes it we can leave a paragraph description on the list and have a direct link to the main page. Cody2526 21:57, 12 December 2006 (UTC)

But if you go to a Star War Wikia and go to the video game section, they sometimes have their articles with two sentence but I'll hold back and see what happens first because I don't want to start another conflict like we had with Gonbe and Chimney. I'll let you do it your way but in the future it might change.