Forum:4 Kids Episodes Edits

New articles were created for the various 4 Kids edits on single episodes. You can find them at Special:UncategorizedPages. However, I don't think that we need separate articles for them. This information should better be included into the episodes articles. They have a section for this kind of content. At least, many episodes articles are stubs, and I think that it it would be better to improve them instead of creating separate and very specific articles.


 * Because there are many stubs articles that does not mean we should fill the episode with every English version. We can improve articles by adding sections like "Music", "Animation" (errors), "Manga/Anime Differance" rather than 4kids edits section. 4Kids Edits pages need a lot of work some part are wrong or some edits are not mentioned the general layout of the page will change and the article will expanding. Also I like "separate and very specific articles". Tipota 20:06, April 24, 2010 (UTC)


 * But why should we make these sections as separate articles? In my opinon it is better to include them directly into the article. Besides, if every new section will be given an own article, things will never be expanded. I see no reason to have them separated. Everything can be done in one article as well. El Chupacabra 16:32, April 28, 2010 (UTC)

Here is an example of expanded summary of episode 1 (4kids version)

This is an example of 4kids dub comparison another is the German dub comparison article.

Here you can see an example of credit list from Gintama wikia: episode 32.

Now put them together with Japanese, Odex, 4Kids, Funimation Edited/Uncut version with characters list, attack list, animation analysis and anime-manga differences. The article will suffer. Of course, I do not want to skip any of the above sections.

"things will never be expanded" : Yes I remember, was one year ago the episode and chapter articles no one edited the new pages but look now there are people who working on them regularly. Tipota 00:50, April 29, 2010 (UTC)