Talk:Voice of all Things

Keep it?
Ehm... why was this created. Did we have a talk about it??

Its really unecessary...

Yeah, although I think it was created in good faith, the "voice of all things" isn't "a thing", but every "thing" has a "voice" from what I understood, hence the article should rather be on the "voices", but it's still unnecessary. I add Delete, if anyone has something against its deletion speak here.

It's a phenomenon. As such it can be considered a "thing". It's like talking about "soul". You don't talk about individual souls but about the phenomenon as such. Same here.

I guess more precisely it should be the "Ability to hear the voice of all things" (like Haki) but that sounds stupid. I strongly believe that it is the same ability as hearing the voices of the sea kings but since this is speculation it's not in the article but under trivia. But if that is in fact the case, the phenomenon has been mentioned twice in the manga now and deserves a page. If it turns out to be a Haki-related ability or whatever we can still merge it. But for now we should keep it. ~ Neowitch 12:36, December 2, 2011 (UTC)


 * For the ability itself, since it's still a mystery I think it simply should go in the "Ability and powers" of Gol D. Roger. I more interested in what the "voices" are instead. Well let's hear other opinions.

We know next to nothing about it. We don't even have an official translation and half of the article is speculation. It was mentioned once in context and not expanded. This will be a useless stub. I propose either deleting it or redirecting it to Roger's abilities and powers section. 17:22, December 2, 2011 (UTC)

I say delete it.. It's really not official.. Its just a fact.

I'll delete it in a couple hours unless someone comes up with a good reason to keep it. 17:41, December 2, 2011 (UTC)


 * I like more a redirect to Gol D. Roger.


 * I also say redirecting it to roger's abilities and powers(JetGatlingGun00 18:00, December 2, 2011 (UTC))

Delete it. SeaTerror 18:11, December 2, 2011 (UTC)