User talk:Genocyber

Shakky beng Sonia's daughter
Where'd you get this conclusion from again cause it's kinda really seems misinterpreted? Shakky was an adult 20 years ago and 13 year old and below pregnancies are a bit too farfetched.

P.S. It would really be polite if you don't erase messages even when matters are resolved. It at least shows documentation so that people won't be confused or likewise when they encounter matters similar to the previous ones.Mugiwara Franky 10:49, July 8, 2010 (UTC)


 * Is this the page and /or this where you got your conclusion that Shakky is Sonia's daughter? Rayleigh is saying that Shakky is fine since Nyon left Sabaody. He is also saying that Nyon's 3 adopted daughters look so different since he last saw them 13 years ago. As to Sonia's line that's just a compliment similar to someone saying, "Yeah, that's our Tom" or something like that.


 * There is also this scene in Chapter 0 where a really grown up Shakky is greeting Hatchan 20 years ago.


 * On similar notes:
 * Where did you get the conclusion that Sonia's not blood related to Hancock?
 * Where did you get the conclusion that Sonia really admired Luffy and wanted to see him?
 * Mugiwara Franky 05:44, July 9, 2010 (UTC)


 * The "That's my Shakky" can't really mean that she's referring to Shakky as her daughter. The Chapter 0 scene contradicts the conclusion that Sonia is Shakky's mother.


 * The first time we see Sandersonia after Hancock returns to Amazon Lily is where she is worried about her sister not eating. The other Amazons were the ones who were excited about his return as seen here. Sandersonia is not among them being excited but is seen escorting her sister.


 * It is actually said in the manga that they are sisters in the very first scene that they are introduced. They maybe physically different from one another but it is specifically stated that they are related.


 * They also didn't escape from a slave camp. They were freed by Fisher Tiger when he attacked Mariejoa.


 * Not to question you or anything, but you may need a little rereading of past chapters.Mugiwara Franky 09:10, July 9, 2010 (UTC)


 * The Mangastream scan apparently is wrong. In here, Sandersonia doesn't say, "That's my Shakky" but "Good one, Shakky".Mugiwara Franky 09:47, July 9, 2010 (UTC)