File talk:Hody Jones Portrait.png

really...
There's a difference between changing your appearance DRASTICALLY and just stop being a pirate. If someone turns 30->90 in like a day there's a difference rather than just "stop being a pirate and change your clothes". We always replace old images if the character has changed their physical appearance (No, wounds are not included -_-, don't even start.).

Well if he's not considered a "pirate" anymore as an old man, then a separate portrait would be best to solve this edit war. But if it's not said anywhere, then the old portrait remains as his pirate portrait as well. 20:36, February 4, 2013 (UTC)

It doesn't even matter if he's a pirate or not, he changed his physical appearance, he's an old man, not a young fishman.

What matters in this case is if he is still considered a pirate as an old man. Nada and Calu think that the moment he was arrested, he was no longer a pirate anymore. If that's the case (if it's said anywhere), then his pirate portrait should reflect how he looked as a pirate (like the roger pirates portraits, or Aokiji in the marines). 20:38, February 4, 2013 (UTC)

We don't know if he's a pirate or not, as you saw, he wouldn't stop yelling at the royals about his revenge, so obviously he hasn't given up on his ambitions.

Ok then. I'm just waiting on Nada to give us this "proof" that Neptune said they weren't, that he mentioned in his description. 20:42, February 4, 2013 (UTC)

Neptune put him behind bars. He didn't "say" it, he doesn't have to. The pirates are captured, so they're no longer active. Until they can break out, they're inactive. 20:58, February 4, 2013 (UTC)

They're still pirates.

They're still inactive. 21:06, February 4, 2013 (UTC)

That has nothing to do with it.

Welp no good evidence from Nada (No surprise). It stays the same. 21:15, February 4, 2013 (UTC)