User blog comment:Ricizubi/Do you believe that the 10th memeber is Shirahoshi? or Jinbei?/@comment-3252861-20110512142017

I don't think so. Shirahoshi is no close to a fighter. Vivi atleast had the basic. Shirahoshi has never fight in her life. Jimbe is strong, but he is no Strawhat. He doesn't has the weird look and character that all Strawhats do. He also has enough experience as pirate and no reason to become again.