Talk:PX-0

Validity
This isn't a "mistranslation" SeaTerror-san. This is actually stated in Kuma's article (last sentence of his introduction paragraph), and is therefore a valid redirect. Mr. Whatever (talk) 20:11, September 6, 2014 (UTC)

Nope. Nobody would ever search for this. SeaTerror (talk) 20:12, September 6, 2014 (UTC)

SeaTerror-san,. As you can see, it has been searched for.

We have redirects such as... Absa, that redirect to Absalom. What's wrong with using an alias here? (And here, it's not even an alias. He is no longer Kuma, but is PX-0). Mr. Whatever (talk) 20:15, September 6, 2014 (UTC)

That screenshot doesn't prove it has ever been searched for. The only thing it lists is what is on the articles. SeaTerror (talk)

Well, i did searsh for it  once  20:19, September 6, 2014 (UTC)

Redirects are created for people to more easily access articles that they might search for. If someone refers to Kuma as PX-0 in the anime, maybe the anime watcher will search for that in the one piece wikia, and this article will pop up immediately. It's just convenient, and I don't understand what you will achieve by deleting redirects. Are you trying to free some space from wikia's servers? This article is 63 bytes. Compare that to Monkey D. Luffy's history page which is 220,096 bytes. Maybe you oughta spend time on rewriting long sentences instead.

The message I just typed is 595 bytes. You're actually wasting space by trying to delete these redirects, you know.

Nobody is going to search for it. The reason to delete the useless ones is because they clutter up the categories. Also I loled at your wasting space comment. SeaTerror (talk) 20:42, September 6, 2014 (UTC)

People might search for it. Take Lord Gaimon here for example. If he searched for it there's a reason for it being here. Unless you have actual website statistics on this particular redirect you can't just blurt out that argument.

What do you mean by cluttering up the categories? Are you implying that the category should be empty? The category is there for a reason, and the more articles put in it the merrier, as it means it is put to good use. There should be plenty of redirects in a wikia, it means it's more user-friendly. A wikia without redirects is a very annoying wikia to browse through.

Nobody is looking through the Redirect category SeaTerror-san (well.. except for you, since you look through it to delete valid redirects). Mr. Whatever (talk) 20:54, September 6, 2014 (UTC)

Doflamingo calls him "PX-0" in chapter 560, making it a legitimate alternate name. I can see no reason why this is not a valid redirect on that front. If you're just opposed to having more redirects, focus your discussion in Forum:Mistranslations as Redirects, which currently requires more discussion. 21:23, September 6, 2014 (UTC)