User blog comment:Stone Roger/Can Shanks defeat BB or not?/@comment-108.4.14.115-20110206160552

i think the only reason that shanks got those scar from teach is that they were on different crews, shanks being on rogers crew and teach being on WB's crew, i think they probabli didnt kno of each others exsistince until their crews clashed, now this is how i see it : the roger pirates invaade the moby dick and have an all out brawl with the WB pirates while shanks and buggy are back to back fighting BB comes out of nowere and claws shanks in the eye shanks being lucky enough to close his eye before the attck gets up and fights him.

please tell me this makes sense or not because it looks kinda confusing lol