I have a feeling that she's evil, I also think that what she whispered to luffy was a proof.
It's not a proof yet but I think it will be a proof.
she wishpers something to luffy... and then CRIES... which makes your theory inaccurate... but it can be she's evil... but not related to what she said to Luffy...
Still pudding personality prove the opposite
All doubts about Pudding being evil disappeared last chapter. I think ever since the reveal on Zou that the Samurais and Minks were actually friends when we all thought the opposite, we all got trust issues from it ;-;
What do you think?