If Ace were yo somehow be revived and join the straw hats would that ruin the story?
If Ace were yo somehow be revived and join the straw hats would that ruin the story?
It depends. There is an overly simplistic way in which I could describe Sabo coming back into the story in which most people would think it's actually garbage. However, Oda was able to do it in such a way where Sabo wasn't just an carbon copy of Ace and I honestly didn't mind that much as a consumer. In fact, I think I can say I like Sabo more than Ace, but that's partly because I don't like Ace that much as a consumer.
So, there is probably a way in which Oda could write it where it turns out amazing. It would just must likely do one of two things. It would be garbage because it likely isn't in line with Oda already has in mind. Or Oda would have to go an entirely different direction in order to make it cohesive and good.
In short, because One Piece is complete fiction Oda has time to do literally most anything that makes sense and fit it into the story if he's good enough.
For example,
-Oda would need to establish some method in which Ace could be fully revived, not just his body being used as a shadow.
-Oda would need to establish a good reason as to why this revival system has never been used before. Or if it has Oda should setup time to foreshadow that people who we though might have been dead are actually alive.
-Oda would need to resolve any Ace-Blackbeard issues whether that be through battle or just have Ace grow as a person to not let it define him.
-Oda would probably need a way to cancel the use of this revival system in order to ensure death is meaningful. Otherwise why don't we revive Oden or Whitebeard?
I'm not a writer, but those are things off the top of my head Oda should address were he to go down this path. There are probably many other things Oda would need to establish as well in order to turn this into a development that isn't garbage and in fact is good and cohesive with the current story.
I think if ace was ever to be revived he would become and even stronger pirate but still keeping ties with his former white beard crew members and would play the same role that sabo plays to Luffy kind of like a role model. But it would be great if we saw Ace Sabo and Luffy together again
I would not like, but I totally agree with Aurius.
It would depend if the revival would make sense or not ...
I particularly don't like histories were people don't die..
If u wanna be true to reality some main characters have to die, people die
Irrevocably
What do you think?