Btw the reason why there isn't Law, Reyleigh and Kuma is because I see them as above YC1 who could contest with Admirals.

@RankMaster722 Yamato actually scales slightly above YC1 for me but since this is a Commander list Id put Yamato at second right behind Beckmen, And Doffy and Ace haven’t shown Island level feats, Those are actually Country level feats due to the size of the One piece planet, And Queen wouldnt be overrated if he was in the YC1 tier Imo

@Fusion D King Yamato still hasn't shown attack power greater than Zoro or King to put her that high. She was barely able to draw blood from Kaido.

The size of a country vastly varies from each island as the OP world is made up of multiple massive islands. When Ace and BB clashed we saw their powers engulfed the entire island. Now if we think Sabo is stronger than Ace(which most ppl do) he'd be able to do the same feat or even better. Which also puts him above Yamato.

No shot Queen is standing a chance against the other YC1, the dude got low diffed by Sanji.

@RankMaster722

1. Yamato having "Higher AP" or "Who injured Kaido more is stronger" does not put a character above or below in terms of whose stronger, Have you seen Yamatos Hax, Haki, And Endurance/Stamina? Because of her DF Hax and Haki she can give a very good fight to an Admiral like Greenbull

2. Yes those are massive Islands but which are country sized because the One piece world is much bigger the normal world being earth, No one knows the exact size but if you calculate it a lot its roughly the size of Jupiter meaning in this scale 6-A = 6-B which is Country = Continent in the One piece world, And pretty much everyone or must people here scale to 6-A or 6-B due to some here being much stronger then Chingao who split a Continent in Dressrosa

3. Yes he got low diffed by Sanji, Doesnt make Queen weak, It makes Sanji strong

@Fusion D King

I don't see ice as a Hax ability. Yeah she has endurance and speed. But guys like Zoro, King and Katakuri has much better Armament, Observation, Durability and Attack Power. I doubt her ACoC is better than Zoro's who scared Kaido and clipped King's wing. Also she didn't do much against Aramaki, he basically commented on her haki and brushed it off.

I think you're comparing the OP world's country to our world. Yes it is bigger but in the OP world islands can be country and vice versa. Most countries in OP are islands.

A YC1 shouldnt be getting low diffed by another YC1, if you really think Queen is YC1 level. That's like if Marco got low diffed by Kid or Sabo.

@RankMaster722

1. Yamatos AP and DC is above Katakuri, Meanwhile King and Zoro is debatable, Yes they have better Armanent and Observation but what about Conquerors?

Also she and Aramaki didnt even have a proper battle since many others were involved, Also yes correct but Im talking about if Aramaki and Yamato had a proper 1v1

2. The One piece world is much larger then our world and if its around the size of Jupiter that means it has roughly 11 times more diameter then Earth and saying "Countries are Islands" In the OP world doesnt mean we put the scale of Doffy and Ace to around Island level since to our world thats around the size of a Continent or Large Country

3. I never said that and your acting like I said "Queen is high YC1" I said either at the very bottom of YC1 if your comparing him to Ace or in between YC1 and YC2, Or at the top of YC2

I dont downplay a characters abilities

Bruh how tf is Magellan on the list but Law is nowhere to be found on it? XD

@Fusion D King

Kat can easily dodge Yamato's attacks as he was able dodge Snakeman which even Kaido needed FS to dodge. Plus he has Awakening. ACoC wise Zoro is also stronger as ACoC basically amplifies attack power.

Lol Yamato stands no chance against an Admiral in 1v1, we've seen Admirals fight multiple Commanders at the same time already. The best she can do is stall.

Again you're comparing the OP world to our world, which isn't fair cuz we know that the OP world is much bigger in scale. Since we're comparing character feats from the OP world we have to use the OP world as reference not real world and in OP world most countries are islands. Wano is a prime example it's a massive island which is also a country.

That's what I'm saying doe, no YC1 low diffs another YC1 no matter high or low they are. Okay another example, that's like saying if Crocodile low diffed Shiryu.

@RankMaster722 Did I say Yamato stands a chance against an Admiral? No

1. Theres a difference between giving a decent or “okay” fight then standing any chance, Also Katakuri cannot “Easily” dodge Yamatos attacks when he was struggling with G4 Snakemans C/Speed, Also yes you are correct that Zoros ACoC is better then Yamatos but that doesnt mean “All she can do is Stall” Because of her feats shes still around High YC1

2. Your correct about Wano since it is a country which is also a Massive Island but if however lets say theres a character having enough DC to destroy the entirety of Wano and Wano is the size of a very large country compared to our world but its an Island in the One piece world does that mean we scale that character to “Island level” No because that Island is the size of a large country or small continent comparing to our world

3. “No YC1 can low diff another YC1” Im saying that queen if compared to Ace should probably be in between the scale of YC1 and Admiral but a little facing towards YC2 in the scale, Queen being a YC1 makes no sense since he got low diffed by another YC1 character Sanji and on your scale you put Sanji under Katakuri and King when I would say hes above both if we check his Speed feats, I have him blitzing Katakuri Mid diff, And again Im saying, Just because Sanji low diffs Queen doesn’t necessarily mean queen is weak but it means Sanji is strong and definitely a High YC1 character on parr with Zoro or very near his level

@Fusion D King

Katakuri was dodging Snakeman's attacks just fine he was even tagging Luffy. Fast forward to Kaido needed FS to dodge Snakeman which he wasn't even using against Yamato. That's just goes to show how good was Kat's FS. Also every YC1 can stall an Admiral so Yamato being able to stall one isn't good enough reason for her to be above others.

Again It's kinda disingenuous to use the real world to scale the OP world. The OP world scales way bigger than our world, so we can't use real world to scale the feats of the OP verse. An island is still an island regardless if its a country or not. I'm just going by what we have Seen in the story and we've seen Ace and Doffy's abilities cover an entire island. Btw Dressrosa is also an island which is also a country.

You just said Queen is YC1 in your previous replies, now you're saying he isn't.😅 So is he YC1 or not? If he is YC1 he shouldn't be getting low diffed by Sanji. Even Zoro(high YC1) isn't low diffing Crocodile.