In his prime, Whitebeard would win

The last we saw of both... If Blackbeard manages to touch Whitebeard, he can even one-shot him

What on earth do you mean

Prime Whitebeard > Blackbeard > Old Whitebeard

@L725 since he can cancel his df and Whitebeard is too old to use properly his weapon only

That’s old Whitebeard, it wasn’t specified in the poll but I’d argue Prime Whitebeard would take out current Blackbeard easily

Blackbeard had to wait until after Whitebeard fought in an entire war while dying from some disease to make an attempt on his life and, even then, he was still getting rocked. Without some dirty tactic or the Tremor-Tremor Fruit, Teach isn’t beating any version of Whitebeard.