I highly doubt it. Roger is more or less equal to Prime WB as well, and I highly doubt Luffy will ever surpass this level. It'll probably be more like the Tanjiro never becoming the greatest DS of all time as even various hashira and Yoriichi still are above him. Or Ichigo never being the greatest Shinigami.

Luffy simply will be too young and probably inexperienced to be the strongest. Not to mention, Kaido is possibly still stronger than current Luffy is and I really don't see him closing such a massive gap in power

@InevitaPICKLE where did you get that Bajrang Gun can only destroy an island???

Its the SIZE of an island, it can destroy a lot more than that

Also, Chinjao didn’t split ice on top of a continent. The ice WAS the continent (it’s literally called the ice continent) and it was said to be especially strong ice with some weird properties.

It also wasn’t a thin layer, it went down as far as we could see on the panel

Also prime Whitebeard is strong, but he’s not in a completely different league from Luffy and Kaido.

He’d beat them, but it’d be a hard fight.

Where did you get that Bajrang Gun can only destroy an island???

... Because at FP the only thing it did was destroy an island and nothing proves it's capable of more

Its the SIZE of an island, it can destroy a lot more than that

You have any statements or feats backing that statement other than headcanon? Probably not cuz there isn't any.

Also, Chinjao didn’t split ice on top of a continent. The ice WAS the continent (it’s literally called the ice continent) and it was said to be especially strong ice with some weird properties.

Breaking a layer of ice doesn't make you continent level. Yes the ice is the continent and did he destroy it? No. To be continent level you have to actually break and destroy a continent, not just crack it.

It also wasn’t a thin layer, it went down as far as we could see on the panel

If this is a genuine continent as you say, then far into the panel isn't even that huge still. But even assuming he split it, that doesn't mean he destroyed it. Huge difference. Also, we see Garp at Full Power (the same garp that could one shot Chin Jao) when he uses Galaxy Impact... And it just destroys a city. To put things in context, even during his training Garp in his prime (who is considered one of the strongest characters to date) was struggling to destroy mountains.

Also prime Whitebeard is strong, but he’s not in a completely different league from Luffy and Kaido. He’d beat them, but it’d be a hard fight.

Oh interesting. It seems you haven't seen the show then. Although all are yonko, prime WB is one tapping both of them. The dude goes toe to toe with Prime Roger my guy. I'm trying to keep this as polite as possible, but dude you'd have to be insane to say that WB high diffs Luffy.

1. It didn’t hit an island. It launched a dragon through an island into a lava pool. And the evidence for it destroying more than an island is it being the size of an island and infused with advanced conqueror’s Haki. A fist the size of an island is enough on its own, much less adding that much force to it

2. I think splitting a continent in half is a continental feat

3. We have no reason to assume Garp was in his prime then, he was literally training. He also trained by destroying multiple mountains. Plus old Garp is not prime Garp.

4. Whitebeard would NOT oneshot any Yonko, are you insane? He’s stronger than Roger, who also couldn’t do that. Nobody in the verse can beat a Yonko that easily. It’s genuinely insane that you think Whitebeard could oneshot a Yonko lmao

You seem to think the Old Gen were absolute gods, with no competition at all, and that’s just not true. Sure, they were the strongest, but not by much.

Kaido would give Roger or Whitebeard a solid fight. Luffy not as much, but he’d last a while.

It didn’t hit an island. It launched a dragon through an island into a lava pool. And the evidence for it destroying more than an island is it being the size of an island and infused with advanced conqueror’s Haki.

Thanks. That proves nothing lol. There's a BIG difference between island level feats and continental I don't think people realise that. Your average continent is around (if you add all the sizes of the continents and divide by 7) 8138571.42857 square miles. Even assuming Onigashima is the size of say, all of Hawaii (which rounds up to 11k square miles) the average continent comes out to about 750 times the size of an island. Even taking into account the smallet coninent Australia, it's still 250 times bigger than that.

Or if you take in to account bigger island's like Madagascar (which is 230k ish square feet where most other big islands are around 200k square feet). That's still 35 times bigger not to mention Onigashima is obviously not the size of Madagascar to begin with Luffy's fist being the size of an island means nothing.

A fist the size of an island is enough on its own, much less adding that much force to it

No it's not but ok. Ig I can start punching through cars by dropping my fist on them now. And this somehow makes Luffy planetary lol.

I think splitting a continent in half is a continental feat

Again, we have no reason to believe he split it in half, but continental

We have no reason to assume Garp was in his prime then, he was literally training. He also trained by destroying multiple mountains. Plus old Garp is not prime Garp.

Whitebeard would NOT oneshot any Yonko, are you insane?

I never said that but thank you for taking it out of context

He’s stronger than Roger, who also couldn’t do that.

Wait what? WB is stronger than Roger now? Since when? You're losing more and more credibility here buddy

Nobody in the verse can beat a Yonko that easily. It’s genuinely insane that you think Whitebeard could oneshot a Yonko lmao

WB is capable of going toe to toe with Roger's strongest attack. I'm pretty positive Roger easily dismantles a Yonko. Maybe he doesn't instantly beat Kaido, but he most definitely easily beats Luffy. Luffy's struggling with Admiral Kizaru here man. Admiral Kizaru isn't even strong enough to take on the right hand man of Shanks.

Shanks, using a weak imitation of Roger's attack one shot the man who, teaming up with someone the same level as him took down Big Mom. So yes, I'm inclined to belive WB, who's equal to Roger one taps at the bare minimum Luffy and low-mid diffs Kaido. He most definitely doesn't high diff them. Seeing how many believe current Luffy is actually on Kaido's level, if not just slightly below it, yeah. I'm pretty sure they get completely destroyed. But anyway. I'm dropping this point from this point onward as it has nothing to do with what I'm trying to prove

Honestly I’m not even interested in scaling Luffy anymore, I’m still just trying to understand your scaling for Roger and Whitebeard

Also I meant that Whitebeard wouldn’t oneshot ANY of the Yonko. Not implying that you said he could oneshot any one of them. Though if he could oneshot Kaido then he could oneshot any of them.

And yeah, Primebeard > Roger. Roger was never said to be the strongest pirate, Whitebeard was, and Whitebeard has everything Roger has + a great devil fruit.

And Roger wouldn’t easily beat a Yonko.

And Kizaru isn’t weaker than Beckmann. He stopped an attack ONCE because he didn’t notice him, then proceeded to immediately attack anyway.

And for the stuff with Kid:

1. He’s not an equal to Law, he’s far weaker. He has 0 Haki feats and never took an advanced conqueror’s attack before that point. Legitimately he arguably scales below Zoro and Sanji.

2. They beat Big Mom because she wasn’t taking them seriously, she didn’t even use basic Haki until the very end, and that was only against Law. Plus they were lucky enough to be on an island 10,000 feet in the air with a nuke’s worth of bombs above a lava pool.

Well idrc about where the yonko scale in terms of the Pirate King and whatever so I'll concede my point and say you're right. I'm just trying to wrap my head around how you got Luffy to planetary when he clearly isn't... So if you're done debating the original topic we can stop here

Well ... Is that a concession then? Or you just gonna not respond?