128 Votes in Poll
@Teslamyman1 big mom towers over garp, big mom is around 25-28ft. and garp is only 8-9ft. but that has nothing to do with it, big mom is relative to kaido, old garp has no chance
@Sxaverio I dont wanna sound rude but, Garp is winning. you can scale shoot with that logic. you mean to tell me that facing BB's crew + Avalo and Kuzan isn't a Yonko level feat? Being big does not mean she is stronger infact it doesnt change anything at all (maybe defense and other things). and keep in mind, he only showed us his weakest galaxy impact. Old Garp is like Mid-High Yonko level. and IF you want to downplay him then call him YC+.
Youre overestimating Garp, he was always a top tier so “facing” bb pirates isn’t too crazy of a feat (especially to put him mid-high yonko lvl at his age) but he didn’t win and even admitted himself he was weak, getting too old and out of his prime. garp only was able to beat on kuzan like he did because kuzan’s will was weak. i never claimed her size had anything to do with the matchup or strength it’s the opposite, this why reading comprehension is so important. and yes garp is around YC1 - very low yonko lvl. and that isn’t enough to beat big mom who’s relative to the world’s strongest creature, someone roger didn’t even wanna fight
Old does not mean weak btw. half of the BB pirates are yc1 level and assuming that kuzan is relative to kizaru or akainu that is easily a Yonko level feat. infact thats an underestimation on your end. and dont forget BB defeated law who is YC1-YC+. and as we know kuzan > BB. Kuzan got overwhelmed by garp. garp pushing kuzan to high-extreme diffing him. Garp has shown feats of Mid-High Yonko and again if you want to downplay him, lets say he is YC+-Low yonkou
Where is it said that Kuzan > BB? Blackbeard is a Yonko. Also, Boa Hancock have managed to defeat several BB Titanic Captains despite being barely above YC.
Even Garp himself stated that Kuzan was holding back during their fight.
Kuzan scared Blackbeard during the flashback
Why would BB be scared if he could win against Kuzan
BB was also scared against Rayleigh (who confessed that he couldn't defeat him) and against S-Hawk. He's just a coward.
"Where is it said that Kuzan > BB? Blackbeard is a Yonko. Also, Boa Hancock have managed to defeat several BB Titanic Captains despite being barely above YC.
Even Garp himself stated that Kuzan was holding back during their fight."
Kuzan has the feats for being greater than BB in strength
If you want to talk about kuzan holding back keep in mind that kuzan was being pushed to high diff by garp
Half of those captain were Yc2-Yc1. Yc3 at the least
Kuzan's only feat is lasting 10 days against Sakazuki, which is not enough to put him above Current BB since MF BB was confident that he could defeat both Garp and Sengoku, who were obviously stronger than Akainu.
Kuzan's feats put him at Admiral Level, which is still below Yonko Level.
Now if you said the Big Mom that was fighting Kaido for 1-3 days, then I'd pick her without a doubt since she was using advanced conquerors and likely advanced armament during their fight. But the Big Mom that was fighting Kid and Law purposefully nerfed herself and never used advanced armament and or advanced conquerors against them which is why she lost. She honestly would've won if she did use her advanced haki, but Oda had to nerf her so Kid and Law could pull off a win.
What do you think?