5,590 Pages

Forums: Index → Candidates for Deletion →  Dub Piece
Note: This topic has been archived because the discussion is considered solved.
Do not add to it unless it really needs to be reopened. Consider creating a brand new forum instead.

  • [[Dub Piece]]
  • Reason: I see no point in this being here. It is not a official version nor a sub, it is a joke. Sure a little famous one, but I can't believe we have it here.
  • Nominator: One-Winged Hawk 08:00, 7 February 2007 (UTC)

Agree: It's nothing but a bunch of Anti-4Kids flame. Read the rules, no articles should be filled with flame and bashing towards 4Kids. Please respect 4Kids if you wanted to mock 4Kids, put that in your personal profile.

This is not an encyclopedic article, it's just bunch of mock ups. This don't deserve it's here. I personally don't like what I read in that article and it's too childish. This article is pure fandom. ( Joekido 08:24, 7 February 2007 (UTC))

Comment: Okay I'll list a bigger reason to get rid of it.

Lets put some serious thought here. Okay if it was a serious dub, that tried to match the series from episode 1 to current... I'd support its stay. It has no relevance to the plot nor does it prove any use. I classify it under [[fanfiction]], because it is more or less. On professional terms, it isn't really something we can boast about. Someone new to One Piece would get a bad impression of it from watching that stuff (as far as funny goes... I'm not impressed, I've only laughed once in the entire lot, but thats an opinion not fact).

Even if it wasn't a company producing it, but fans (which can happen with anime) I'd vote it in if it wasn't as it is. And even if isn't funny, but tried to translated whole episodes instead of random cut and slap clips together... I would vote it in. But its is nothing to boast about. Even if that article is not deleted, I would say treat it like the sub articles - keep the detail simple and not bother with extended detailed stuff.

My 2 cents. Maybe its the wikipedian coming out in me... But I remember when someone created a page for it on there, it was deleted within a couple of hours. still, at least we haven't linked to YouTube on the page. One-Winged Hawk 08:34, 7 February 2007 (UTC)

It also counts as "self advertising" but apparently... I forgot to write that into our rules. Its one rule, but its meant to stop articles like links to galleries on Deviantart and accounts to YouTube and things like that getting on. It also prevents people trying to sell stuff on here. ^-^' One-Winged Hawk 08:39, 7 February 2007 (UTC)

Comment: I updated my decision. At first I did not read the article and just post the comment down, however I read the whole article and realize why it should be deleted and decided to agree with you Angel, that page must burn in hell. Sorry.

( Joekido 08:42, 7 February 2007 (UTC))

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.