​

Editing

Talk:Kin'emon

2
  • This is a talk page. Please remember to sign your posts using four tildes (~~~~) or the signature button
  • The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit. If you are undoing an edit that is …
This is a talk page. Please remember to sign your posts using four tildes (~~~~) or the signature button
+
Latest revision Your text
Line 85: Line 85:
 
But it's really not the case here in my opinion. As you say, we don't know the time it takes for the gas to kill people. Characters say that victims are dead, but they don't know more than us, as far as we know they just see them changed into statues after having been hit by "killer gas" and assume they're dead—anyone would probably react the same. Caesar (the only character who actually knows about the gas) says that they're doomed, but was never really specific.{{br}}
 
But it's really not the case here in my opinion. As you say, we don't know the time it takes for the gas to kill people. Characters say that victims are dead, but they don't know more than us, as far as we know they just see them changed into statues after having been hit by "killer gas" and assume they're dead—anyone would probably react the same. Caesar (the only character who actually knows about the gas) says that they're doomed, but was never really specific.{{br}}
 
What I mean is that we should stick to the facts. Fact: the gas is said to kill, but not instantaneously. Fact: Brook thinks Kinemon's dead. That's all. We can state that he's believed to be dead. But it's not enough to put him in the category. {{br}}
 
What I mean is that we should stick to the facts. Fact: the gas is said to kill, but not instantaneously. Fact: Brook thinks Kinemon's dead. That's all. We can state that he's believed to be dead. But it's not enough to put him in the category. {{br}}
Actually, now that I think about it, there used to be a category specifically designed for these cases: {{Redlink|Category:Presumed Deceased}}. It was deleted as speculative, but I don't think it is, if correctly used. In any case, it's better to use it than to mix confirmed and unconfirmed deaths. {{User:sff9/sig|21:35, December 17, 2012}}
+
Actually, now that I think about it, there used to be a category specifically designed for these cases: [[:Category:Presumed Deceased]]. It was deleted as speculative, but I don't think it is, if correctly used. In any case, it's better to use it than to mix confirmed and unconfirmed deaths. {{User:sff9/sig|21:35, December 17, 2012}}
   
 
Restoring that category would be the best way to end this argument.{{User:DancePowderer/Sig}} 21:51, December 17, 2012 (UTC)
 
Restoring that category would be the best way to end this argument.{{User:DancePowderer/Sig}} 21:51, December 17, 2012 (UTC)
  Loading editor

See this template